[Archive November 27, 2005]
Well, the Pope John Paul II (1920-2005) television movies are upon us. I missed Hallmark Channel’s "Karol, A Man who Became Pope" this past August because I don’t have basic cable. (Am I cheap or just wise?) The life of one of the longest reigning Popes in history (26 years) who had 104 foreign trips, 14 Encyclicals, 45 or so Apostolic Letters, thousands of homilies and speeches, and, by the way suffered under both Nazism and Communism in his native Poland and, by the way lost his mother at a young age, is going to be condensed into 2 hour and 4 hour movies. Good luck to the producers.
I’ve heard that CBS’ version will be better than ABC’s version, but I’ll wait and see.
Thursday December 1st at 8pm ET ABC-TV:
“Have No Fear: The Life of Pope John Paul II” (2 hours)
Sunday December 4th and Wednesday December 7th CBS-TV:
"Pope John Paul II" (4 hours total)
Just as most U.S. and world history from elementary school to high school and beyond is focused upon the 1960s, I suspect that the story of Pope John Paul II may be focused disproportionately on "the scandal of 2002." I may be wrong but from what I read so far ABC's program will present it.
Even though a woman portrayed Christ at World Youth Day in Denver, Colorado at the old Mile High Stadium during the Via Crucis in 1993, I understand that actual men (males) will in fact play the role of Karol Wojtyla in these television movies! I don’t want to clutter up this space by elaborating on Hollywood’s recent past projects like The Last Temptation of Christ (1988), Priest (1994), The Saint (1997), Dogma (1999), Stigmata (1999), The Magdalene Sisters (2003), The Order (2003) and Saved (2004). Instead, I’ll save these references for next year’s “DaVinci Crud”... perhaps.
Update December 1,2005:
I watched ABC’s program tonight. It was hard to overlook the fact that the actor who played Karol Wojtyla/John Paul II as an adult did not look, sound, speak, or have any of the mannerisms of John Paul II. Rather, he reminded me of a Clint Eastwood-Steven Segal hybrid. Does anyone recall Pope John Paul II having a 5 o’clock shadow? An emaciated John XXIII also appeared! Also, I have no idea why a 42 year old played an 18 year-old Wojtyla. Disney posted a $516 million profit last quarter. Couldn’t they have hired a young actor for a few bucks?
This was a B movie at best. The most spiritual thing I could find during this 2 hour time block on ABC was “Someone up there loves you … Direct TV™.” At times I thought that I was watching an SNL skit. Basically, I found it to be a waste of time, but I committed myself to watching it.
Although, the producers claimed that it was based on published accounts of his life, one wonders who published these accounts, Dan Brown? If it was “based on published accounts” it wasn’t entirely based on published accounts. I understand “artistic liberty” and all, but “I am only a human being just as Christ was”, for example (one of many), is certainly nothing that John Paul would have said.
The best aspect of this movie-biography was the music. The last 10 minutes with the Pope struggling in old age before the crowds was certainly moving. The May 13, 1981 assassination attempt was also tastefully done. The low-budgetness of this movie was brought home with the superimposed rain at the end during a flashback of a 9 year-old Karol Wojtyla. I’m now really looking forward to CBS’ version.
Update December 4,2005:
The first part of CBS' movie was on tonight. It makes ABC's version look like a cable access show. Yeah baby... Now that's the JP II that we all know! "To stay alive and to stay Polish" is the response I have always heard from those who lived through the German occupation.
Update December 7,2005:
Speechless … the second part was simply awesome. I re-lived last April all over again.
“You must call by name what is good and what is evil and fight with your freedom… You must not hate. You must not kill. …Forgiveness is God’s might” - J.P. II to Lech Walesa
“You are not alone. The living God walks beside you. He will be your best friend.” – J.P. II to the youth.
Photo: Vatican one euro coin © European Central Bank
Tags: John Paul II